CERESUltra

Music Nerd, Author, Yote!

  • She/they/it

30s/white/tired/coyote/&
Words are my favorite stim toy


NireBryce
@NireBryce

people talk about wanting movements but the US is very big and you'll need many movements with their own agility and intel and knowledge of the local political terrain, not national movements. national "connective tissue" type things will be necessary to connect people needing to learn with the people with the skills, but the biggest thing DSA and PSL and etc teach as lessons is that national political organizations are unable and unwilling, due to structural dynamics, pay attention to their locals.

which so far has meant good locals bloom in spite of that body, while bad locals fester because of the lack of oversight or recourse.

but we do need something, because unions are selfish, keeping to their industries. they branch out sometimes, sure, but they don't use their power for things outside their industry much anymore, no matter what people who go to Labor Notes claim.


NireBryce
@NireBryce

there's talk of selfhosting, of friend collectives, of political discords, of countless ways to squander our efforts.

but the only way to make it count is at the municipal level, whether that's mutual aid (the real kind, building structures the gov won't, that become self sustaining) or helping people with hosting, or websites, or whatever. build study groups where you just talk about what's going on, not even left theory unless someone asks, not to cloak it, but because if it worked we wouldn't still be discussing it eight years later. the left is small, so just be gentle with people -- no one has time to learn unless this is their hobby. yes, that means you're a hobbiest, even if you're dedicated to the cause, because "the masses" can't relate to half the things you talk about. perhaps not to your face, but where have most of them gone the past eight years, who you taught?


NireBryce
@NireBryce

online stuff has a very hard time:

  • preventing evictions.
  • getting people housing that doesn't require them moving out of town
  • getting people fed in ways that aren't cost prohibitive
  • building groups that can do things for the people around them
  • strength in numbers when politicians, or outside forces, become a threat
  • community defense. no, put down the gun, not that kind.
  • disaster response and resilience
  • teaching people skills who will actually put them to work instead of collecting skills to some day use them if there's some need some time (the need's always been there)

etc

online organizing has a place but it can never be the front line, and a whole lot of abled people claim it's all they can do when I spent six years burning energy I didn't have to try and build things largely in spite of people who were mostly on line and only in person when it would be embarrassing not to be.

if you're abled and believe in any form of left ideology, it should always be embarassing not to be out there. be embarrassed. or go build things instead.

part 4


NireBryce
@NireBryce

what makes you think capitalism won't adapt? it's been so good at it these past two decades.

lemmie let you in on a secret

we are the crisis

the structures you build, if they're everywhere, point at what's ignored in the pursuit of profit. it tears holes in the American Myth. it builds self sustaining institutions of the community, with a leftward ideological bent. service and education in one.

hoarding your supplies and your skills and working on an org for a crisis that never comes, as things get worse and worse and those with power figure out ways to capitalize on that suffering is cultism at best. we don't need 500 groups reinventing the wheel while refusing to collaborate, and that's why the future is networks and not organizations imo.

i know a lot of other places are saying this. they're right. i may seem like a copycat but this is from like. thirteen years of experience at this point. occupy was right in that sense.

and hey, even if nothing comes from it, you did something for you community.

who am i to tell you what to do, I'm just some dyke with an internet connection. do it for everyone else.

edit to be clear: this isn't "organize with the centrist democrats to run their candidate. this is the fastest route to build power. ignore the Dems, make them keep up if they don't want to defect.


Keloti
@Keloti

If I want to learn about organizing on a municipal level in a starting-from-scratch scenario, what should I read?


NireBryce
@NireBryce

I don't have much to hand out, so boosting this to y'all until i end up finding some. I've been out of practice a few years recuperating


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @NireBryce's post:

not off the top of my head, a lot of this was formed from reading everything else and finding it not applicable but I'm sure others have better lists. if you do this as a share instead of a comment I'll boost

in reply to @Keloti's post:

I asked that question on an activist Slack I'm on and unfortunately didn't get any responses.

So, here's what I've got, as someone who's worked on and off to pressure San Francisco City government, sometimes successfully, sometimes less so.

First stop I'd recommend is the Indivisible Guide. It is not written for municipal advocacy; it's written for Federal advocacy (by former Congressional staffers). But it will give you a good 10,000 foot overview of what pressuring government looks like, and some initial tactics ideas.

Next, dig into how your local government is structured. Every city is different. Every county is also different. Some questions to start with include:

  • Is the Mayor elected by the people, elected from among the City Council, or appointed by the City Council?
  • How is your City Council elected? Are Councilmembers elected by district, or by the whole city?
  • For the county, how is your Board of Supervisors elected? How many seats are on it?
  • Is there a City Manager or other officer who has broad executive powers but isn't democratically elected? How does that person come to power?
  • What departments does your city have? How do department heads come to power?
  • What gets fobbed off onto the county/state/private companies?
  • For each of the aforementioned offices: What's the term length (e.g., four-year terms)? What's the term phase (e.g., even years, odd years, Presidential years, midterms)? What term limits (if any) apply (e.g., two consecutive terms)?
  • What public comment opportunities exist (e.g., comment at a Board or Council meeting)? How are those opportunities noticed (advertised)? What sorts of things can you comment on?
  • What committees does your City Council or Board have? These are often where legislation begins and may be the first and last opportunity to give comment before an ordinance goes to the full body for passage.

Your city's website should answer at least some of those. If it doesn't, a trip to the local library—or City Hall itself—may be in order.

Some things are separate from city and/or county government. School districts are often separate, at least here in California. Transit authorities often but not necessarily coincide with county lines and may or may not be run by county government. Here, too, there are questions of “how did they get there?”; for example, BART's Directors are elected in public elections, whereas Caltrain's governing board is composed, at least in part, of Supervisors from the counties it serves.

All of this generally follows a similar three-branch structure to Federal and state government. Your Mayor and City Manager are the executive branch; your City Council and Board of Supervisors are the legislative branch; and your city and/or county may have their own courts, the judicial branch. Departments, like Cabinet Departments at the Federal level, are generally under the executive branch (answerable to the Mayor/President), though I'm not sure how that works in most counties.

The main thing you're trying to figure out with the above is: Who's responsible for redressing my grievance? Which specific person do I have to talk to?

If what you want is a change in policy or how policy or law is implemented, you generally want the executive branch—the Mayor or City Manager or one of the Departments. If it's a change in law (an ordinance), you want the legislative branch—the City Council or the Board of Supervisors.

They may or may not be receptive to what you want. Sometimes it's something they already wanted to do! They just never had a constituent ask for it before. Other times you're going to have to figure out where and how to apply pressure—privately at first, then publicly if needed.

Lastly, I highly recommend getting some like-minded friends to join you. Organizing is more fun and sustainable when you have comrades, you can pool skills and knowledge and resources, and your efforts can be more effective when it's more than one person asking for something. Note that it'll generally be easier to attract people to a specific cause/demand—an outcome that people can care about beyond the how of asking government for things.

I hope that's helpful. Sorry I couldn't find anything already existing.