This is a tricky one, because we don't drink anywhere near as much coffee as we used to, and a lot of headmates showed up after we stopped drinking coffee altogether, both due to heartburn and caffeine sometimes being dangerous on my ADHD meds.
Our headmate Molly was fond of any and all coffee before she integrated with Mia, and canonically had a secret minor coffee related superpower, but Mia doesn't carry that same love of coffee with her.
Still, some of us have opinions:
I tend to like strong bold flavors, something with a lot of cinnamon or starts with caramel or hazelnut. I like my coffee with cream but not necessarily with a lot of sugar. Also because I'm absolute masochist, spicy coffee is extremely my jam. When I worked at a summer camp up in the mountains the coffee wasn't very good, so I'd make it better by putting a healthy double shot of Tabasco in it every morning. You better bet your ass I was awake after that, and it did genuinely improve the coffee.
Karinne likes it really sweet. Caramel macchiato is by far her favorite, and she likes really rich creamy foamy sugary coffees. She has an insatiable sweet tooth and loves decadent hot coffee on a cold morning like nothing else.
Jane takes hers either black or with a small amount of whole milk. She used to be fond of sweet creamers, but stopped that dead after we broke up with our ex-husband. She's still very sorry about how all of that went down, and I think it's just one more reminder of a great deal of pain.
Lex doesn't really like coffee all that much, but she was a huge sucker for the monster Nitro cold brew, because she loves energy drinks.
Chase doesn't drink coffee, but I could absolutely see them being a basic white they PSL junkie.
Seras got here long after we stopped drinking coffee, but she remembers us liking chai coffee a lot, and says she'd choose that.
Harvey will probably drink anything but he doesn't really care, and Haveck and Mia really aren't coffee people.