Campster

Regret Elemental

Maker of Organic, Artisanal Video Essays About Interactive Media


Was @Campster on Twitter, once.


Still confused when people call him "Errant Signal."


Cringe Elemental


http://patreon.com/errantsignal


It's interesting to play some Fortnite after playing a bunch of Marvel: Snap all weekend.

It's not like you'll catch me defending Fortnite for it's myriad of issues, but if there's one thing that really does work for the game it's the season pass. It costs $10, runs for about two and a half to three months, comes with a bunch of new cosmetic items, music, loading screens, characters, and emotes to unlock, and its goals are varied and myriad. Among other trials, this season I have: rung doorbells to trick or treat, looked for specific candies during the Halloween event, got bounties from Star Wars Stormtroopers, fought Darth Vader (again), turned myself into an Alex Mack chrome blob and plummeted seven stories without taking fall damage, and had to pick 3 fruits from trees planted by other players in previous matches. It's pretty varied!

Meanwhile, a $10 season pass in Marvel Snap consists of challenges like play fifteen 2 cost cards, win 15 matches, or win a location with 20 or more power 25 times. And your return for this grind is... a Miles Morales card, a variant Miles Morales card with the same abilities, a bunch of variants to Spider-Man themed cards you already have, and a smattering of upgrade/crafting resources. Woo?

Don't get me wrong: Fortnite only can do this because it operates at scale. Hundreds of programmers and artists are working behind the scenes to ensure that every week a new 3D action adventure is happening in the background of Fortnite's battle royale, and it can't operate that way /without/ that exploitation. But at the same time: $10 for a month-long grind for one or two exclusive cards and a bunch of cosmetics that amount to JPEGs of art done by comic artists years ago (who almost certainly see no royalties) that you earn by just grinding numbers down really isn't as appealing.

I guess what I'm saying is that season passes are either sustainable but probably not worth it, or worth it but probably unsustainable. It is not a great set up.


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @Campster's post:

Although I am enjoying Snap a lot, I totally agree with you here. It's funny how a lot of the decisions that I feel the designers have made to make the game more ethical and streamlined also sadly result in it being...a little more boring and deflating?

I mean even the ethics could be debated, when the answer to everything is "grind for a few hours."

tbh i don't think you can call that game 'ethical' when almost assuredly none of the artists whose work is being used for the cards are gonna see any of that money.

My hot take for a while has been that battle / season passes are -fine- as far as being a kind of "opt-in" sub fee, though that's heavily weighed by having paid MMO sub fees through my teens just to -access- the game. If I'm gonna play 400 hours of Apex a season for free anyway, I don't mind chipping in a tenner for some bonus goodies that are largely useless to me as someone who only plays one character and never puts a skin on them.

That said, I don't know that any BPs are, like, good right now. That they're driven by FOMO (and subcommunities that WANT their passes to be FOMO driven) deeply sucks, and while I was excited for Halo Inf's "FOMO-less" passes, that game had its own bag of frustrations with progression/unlocks.

I never expected to be a Fortnite convert, but then they put a Goku in it. Honestly, all told, I’m having a lot of fun, and even though I don’t “win” a lot of matches, every couple of games I at least have a funny story to tell. Like last week I saw a Deadpool putzing around in a tiny car (an emote you can Pay For of course) and I just started following him and dancing around too. Just two folks having fun ignoring everything else in the world. Emergent stories like that aren’t uncommon in online games, but I feel like Fortnite really facilitates it more than others, due to scale like you said.