My friend @Cassie-Vlodhammer alerted me to this treasure trove of old-web style buttons, all 88x31px. (Warning: that page is VERY image heavy, and animated.)
There's so many fun ones, but for some reason I had a compulsion to make my own. So I made a template and looked up how to make gifs in Photoshop CS6. It's been a lot of fun for me, look at 'em!
You're welcome to use any that strike your fancy, just right-click and copy the image url. Except for GirlToy Jail, that one's just for me. If we're friends and you are very nice to me, I might even make you one. MWAH ๐ love yall.
