Over the summer, for Columbia Pictures' 100th aniversary, Sony re-released all their live action Spider-Man films to movie theaters, one per week, so you could roll into an empty theater on a Monday morning and watch Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, or Tom Holland swing around Manhattan.
I thought it would be worth revisiting the three franchises, so I went every week. Here's my take on the Tobey Maguire films, directed by Sam Raimi.
Spider-Man (2002):
Some of this film is a little cheesy in modern times, because it predates the MCU and its hard push towards dead fucking seriousness. But if you look at this as a comic book in motion, instead of a film that has to have absolute narrative cohesion, logic and pacing, and it hits the mark dead center.
Also, this is probably where the original MCU formula started: take promising small-time directors and give them an entire warehouse full of money to build a blockbuster. They gave the guy that did Evil Dead 2 a 130 million dollar budget and he made a film that pulled in 825 million! This is almost certainly why you got phase 1 Marvel flicks directed by Jon Favreau, Kenneth Branagh, Joss Whedon.
Its CGI is dated now, but 22 years ago, I swear to you this was technological wizardry on a scale no one had seen at the time.
Spider-Man 2 (2004)
I once said there were only two good Spider-Man films ever, and this was one of them, and I am saddened to say I think that less on a rewatching 20 years later.
Without question, Alfred Molina nailed it here. The train scene is still iconic. Sam Raimi got to go full Sam Raimi in the hospital scene. But also it has bonkers plot points like Doctor Octopus robbing a bank while Peter Parker is there trying to get a loan, and Spider-Man losing his powers because he feels ennui or something.
Spider-Man 3 (2007)
Yeah, I know.
But look, just like Spider-Man 2 wasn't as good as I remembered it being, SM3 wasn't nearly as bad.
It's got way too many plot lines and characters--Raimi says he was bullied into writing Venom into the story, unbelievably--and many missteps...but in some unexpected ways, it felt much more mature in narrative than the previous outings. I don't know, I can't quantify it. I braced myself to hate it again, and was surprised to find that I didn't.