JcDent

A T-55 experience

Military history, video games and miniature wargaming.

RPGs, single player FPS, RTS and 4X, grog games.


Passionate about complaining about Warhammer.


Catholic, socialist, and an LGBT+ ally.


FORUM SIGNATURE:
THIS USER IS A GIRL KISSER

///

JUST POST


Fortified Niche: a podcast covering indie miniature wargames
www.anchor.fm/fortified-niche
Grognardia: the current place to order my t-shirt designs [until I find a better one]
www.zazzle.com/store/grognardia

And curiously enough, it's the one mad that made the transition from "mad for reactionary reasons" to "mad for the right reasons" basically intact.

X-Men: The Last Stand draws parallel between the discrimination that the mutants face and homophobia

they even have a parent ask their child "have you tried not being mutant at some point"

They even owned me in the comments section on cracked dot com, saying that the director confirmed that it's a gay alegory

Except that mutants pose an actual threat

A lesbian can't take the Golden Gate bridge for a flight while at the same time disintegrating people without even a glance. No gay guy read your mind, and so on.

An important part of -phobias being -phobias is that they're irrational, that the danger is imagined.

But the Juggernaut can, at will, just start tearing apart downtown - and nobody can stop him.

Well, maybe other mutants.

But at that point you might as well start making a movie about how prejudice against mutants is like gun control, while ignoring the fact that nobody is has an inborn Uzi.


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @JcDent's post:

Is it that much better? Maybe the context at the time was different.

Today, bootlickers already claim that cops need their guns to save them from unstoppable bl- er, drug addicts, you don't need to portray the oppressed as literally having powers.

I'm not entirely sure what conversation we're having right now.

I mean, Professor X was all about peaceful coexistence and Magneto was a reactionary extremist responding to the authoritarian hatred of rich white politicians. I really don't know how else it can be seen.

"Have you tried not being a mutant" is a quote from X2, not Last Stand: https://youtu.be/nxLrH5ydSMM

That aside I get where you're coming for, but mutants have long been used as an allegory for discrimination in America. Very early in the X-Men comic run Xavier and Magneto were rewritten into a Martin vs Malcolm dynamic, with the latter drawing his ideology from surviving the holocaust. This carried into the X-Men Animated Series (albeit in a kid friendly way) which was the primary inspiration for the film universe Singer and Hayter started.

Lmao, I had been convinced of that for ages. What an egg on my face.

...and judging by the comments, the people back then liked it.

Man, how did Star Trek managed it so well with the planet of guys with half-black, half-white faces being against guys with half-white, half-black faces, and X-Men were all "no, the oppressed class has superpowers"

Because Star Trek is a show about aliens and X-Men is a comic book about people with super powers?

I get you were asking rhetorically but that's honestly it. The concept of mutants begs the question of "how would society respond to such a thing" and that question inevitable devolves into "concentration camps and experimentation." It's hard for such a source material to not develop into allegories on our own society.

If that isn't your thing then I just don't think this is a comic series for you, any more than the people who (fairly) look at Batman and go "why is he beating people up instead of using his wealth to improve society."