NireBryce

reality is the battlefield

the first line goes in Cohost embeds

🐥 I am not embroiled in any legal battle
🐦 other than battles that are legal 🎮

I speak to the universe and it speaks back, in it's own way.

mastodon

email: contact at breadthcharge dot net

I live on the northeast coast of the US.

'non-functional programmer'. 'far left'.

conceptual midwife.

https://cohost.org/NireBryce/post/4929459-here-s-my-five-minut

If you can see the "show contact info" dropdown below, I follow you. If you want me to, ask and I'll think about it.


getting people to not convince people to buy a game doesn't harm the terf cause particularly much, when the alternative is all the people shilling the game who would otherwise be propagandizing. sure, the second worst person in the world gets even more infinite money.

let's keep things in perspective. this is a campaign, not singular skirmishes, and the fact that no one good agreed to either the game or the movie shows how much we've gained as a moment in just a handful of years. they're panicked and reacting but even with whipping up their base they still couldn't convince enough people to defect

that's why i think the wired review is good. because, well, it points out the most key fact: trans people have established themselves enough as a movement in industry (and as individual achievement) that so far, it looks like having the reputation of affiliating with a vocal transphobe means you can't hire anyone worth a damn

that wasn't the case even in 2019.

do not focus so much on the huge amounts of money -- it rarely goes to movement when it's hateful people. they like never having to worry even more than they hate us, generally and historically. its the institutions that act as force multipliers, and, well, trans people are in every discipline, as are queer people, these days.

things used to go so slow. they're faster now, but the peaks are still the same.

I do not know how to tell you the perspective from 2007 but... things have come so far even in the forces of reaction. we are so much stronger than we were back then, as a gestalt, and not easily dismissed anymore.

disabling shares because I know I'll get yelled at for talking about how powerful trans people are like this, but yelling at people is pretty low value in terms of where all that energy could be going, even just for outreach or counter lobbying. there's only strength in numbers, and only if you can act together to do things like withhold high quality labor collectively, or get thirty of you to attend municipal council meetings etc. but online on social media you don't control, we're easily blockable randos just yelling at people, so collectively focused on the cheese that we miss the snap trap.


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @NireBryce's post:

If I understand your messages correctly, the people who bought or worked on the game are people who are ok with transphobia (and would have done so anyway) while everyone else have denounced it. That sounds credible. I was worried because of the money it made, but if you tell me that it doesn't matter that much, I believe you. I'll admit, I'm worried. I have never bought that "the arc of the morale universe is long but it bend toward justice"; everything that has be gained can be lost in a moment. But you're right, this specific situation is not as bleak as I thought. So I guess this is a long way for me to appologise for my earlier doomposting.

no worries -- I've been getting a few things like this, so this was more a general thing. I think I replied a bit more exaspirated to your original comment, but that was partially because I was low on sleep (genuinely sorry! mornings)

The buyers will still suck, ofc, but most of them didn't know about Rowling's stuff until they were told loudly. It takes awhile for that to settle in and for them to reflect before they Realize. And the rest are the sort who don't mind that the game that was barely a game was full of anti-Semitism, you know?

I'm not optimistic as much as like, the fights right now are hard, but zoomed out they really do look like we're in the "then they fight you, then you win" part of the cycle. they fight in the open because they've got no other options. (and part of why the arc bends in such a wavy line, is that liberal/centrists are largely a product of engineered ignorance, and create inertia/damping in the side of change)

We're a small community, globally, if the 1% thing is true. But we've managed, through solidarity and pulling each other up whenever we figure something out, to be pretty strong in every creative industry. We're seeing the tip of the ice berg of about two decades of work and activism. I know that change seems slow, but it's more that it takes awhile to build speed. The internet made things so much faster, and once enough of us found each other, we talked enough that they can never put us back into the bottle, because they cannot block all of us, and all we offer is information about truths some people have.

The thing that scares them most is that we're not genetically predisposed. its random. Even the most pure of fascist child could be trans, or gay, and that terrifies them.

I can write more on this, but I figure you don't want double this post length without me asking.

I know it has been 18 days since you posted this, but I told myself I would reply and I just randomely remembered today, so sorry if I am dredging up old post.

I never felt frustration or exasperation in your original comment! I tought you were polite and your reply made sense. There was no overt display of anger or anything. Maybe it's because I have a hard time with reading tones, but I don't see anything like that in your message.