The sentence that might lead to Sheppard & You's actual title is probably getting a rewrite when I do The Big Edit so I'm still not close to an actual title, but in the meantime here's two light novel-esque sentence titles that describe the premise of Sheppard & You, for funsies:
- Your monster boyfriend isn't the only monster in these woods
- You just want a quiet small-town life but you are your monster boyfriend's veterinarian