SamKeeper

Then Eve, Being A Force

Laughed At Their Decision



patreon

games, comics, and books


pfp by @girlpillz


SamKeeper
@SamKeeper

The Auteur as a figure in entertainment is dead. Grown strong on digital production, a more artistically bankrupt creature emerges in their place. It is the Executive Auteur, and it's coming soon to a theater near you, whether you like it or not.

If you've noticed all manner of artists increasingly taking a back seat in the discourse to studios and franchises, if you're weirded out by how much more valued a corporation's vision seems to be than the interchangeable drones tasked with realizing that vision, this article is for you.


outrider
@outrider

I realised the other day it's kind of funny how Ken Williams was strutting around the other year to promote his book acting like he was some kind of highly influential industry luminary when all of Sierra's big hits were created and run by others

Leisure Suit Larry? Al Lowe Space Quest? Two Guys from Andromeda Quest for Glory? Lori and Corey Cole Police Quest? Jim Walls King's Quest? his wife Roberta

the closest thing to a major creative choice he made in a Sierra game was the decision to dump Jim Walls as the lead for Police Quest 4 and instead hire Daryl Fucking Gates


outrider
@outrider

remember how he seemed to think it made him look like a brilliant entrepreneur to brag about how he brought his wife into his job to do the actual work while he messed around on work computers to try and get his business off the ground


SamKeeper
@SamKeeper

it's so weird when this happens with games because I feel like early games fandom-criticism was pretty good at talking about who did what. at least that's the impression I've gotten from the deep knowledge people seem to have of things like "who designed each level in Doom". I'm not sure how we got from that very fine toothed analysis of how games came together to the modern auteur model... maybe it was just easier for news outlets and press releases to handle discussion that way once games became a juggernaut entertainment industry?


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @SamKeeper's post:

I really enjoyed this article! I think there's a lot to be said about art being exactly in the struggle and generally failure to get your ideas and expression across in your chosen medium, and how capitalism, as it seeks to hide and alienate all labor does the same with art, where we truly think of these products as being done by the studios and not the people in them.

yeah and it feels like there's also a weird flip side where the work that the reader does in interpreting a text is also diminished to the point where a text sort of seems to emerge ex nihilo and then enter directly into the reader's brain with an obvious canonical meaning and interpretation.

I actually cut a bunch of stuff (for flow and tone reasons--it's hard to get onto these subjects without going on a whole acerbic tangent) about this kind of co-opting. like, reframing the bad cgi in She Hulk as "policing women's bodies" or whatever. I feel like post-gamergate it's so easy to gesture vaguely at a handful of reactionaries and suggest everyone critical of these franchises is just 4chan scum or Film Bros or whatever. it's very frustrating, and it's made it really hard to even talk about!

Wait this is you?

THIS IS YOU!! HOLY SHIT THAT'S COOL!

I'M SO GLAD SOMEONE HAD THE BALLS TO MAKE THIS ARTICLE. I'M SO IMPRESSED AND AMAZED BY THE AMOUNT OF PEOPLE ON HERE THAT CAN BOTH AGREE OUR SYSTEMS ARE SHIT AND MAKE GOOD POINTS!! I SWEAR TO GOD SOCIAL MEDIA JUST COLLECTIVISES STUPIDITY.

YOU HAVE NO IDEA HOW LONG I'VE NOTICED THIS AND SO DESPERATELY WANTED AN ANSWER.

in reply to @SamKeeper's post:

I mean there are some creatives in games who clearly have a very strong influence on how the games they work on turn out as a whole, for better or worse (the Hideo Kojima <-> David Cage spectrum)

but on the other hand, as they say:

"There's a tendency among the press to attribute the creation of a game to a single person," says Warren Spector, creator of Thief and Deus Ex.

(https://www.ign.com/articles/2001/11/12/deus-ex-2)