• he/him

Avatar by @DrDubz.
Banner by one of Colin Jackson, Rick Lodge, Steve Noake, or David Severn from Bubsy in: Fractured Furry Tales for the Atari Jaguar.


arborelia
@arborelia

In Part 1, I tried to get Software Heritage (SWH) to stop crediting my software called ftfy to my deadname. After I brought it up on Twitter, one of their developers DMed me to tell me that was impossible, because changing names would ruin the “integrity” of their data structures.

I give zero shits about the integrity of their data structures. I had already sent them a second email invoking the Right to Rectification, which it seemed like they ignored again, so it was time to get more formal.

SWH is run by Inria, a French government-supported research organization. I was convinced that the reason their Data Protection Officer felt they could ignore my e-mails was that I was writing them in English.

My level of being able to put together a French sentence is somewhere around « Je vais au supermarché en tren train », but I can kinda read it when there's enough cognates. With a combination of Microsoft Word with grammar checking, Wiktionary, machine translation to suggest sentences, a guide to writing formal GDPR requests in French, and a French acquaintance who was busy but could proofread the result, I got to it.

In the replies to part 1, @IkomaTanomori described “getting legally angry in French” as Western civilization's equivalent of going super saiyan, and that sounds pretty much right.


ireneista
@ireneista

specifically trans people in Europe (anywhere in Europe is probably fine, based on our own knowledge, but we defer to @arborelia on that point. Frances is probably most convenient)

who are being deadnamed by SWH in the fashion described in this thread

comments to original, not to our reply, we're just boosting this in case it helps with visibility. we have nothing to do with this but it infuriates us.


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @arborelia's post:

But also, apparently how you write the salutation in French has none of this indirect English “to whom it may concern” stuff. I'm talking to you, madame. This concerns you.

It does actually:
À l'intention de quiconque cela concerne. Literally, "to the intention of whom it concerns."
"Quiconque" means "whoever."

I'm unsure about Right to Rectification specifically, but they were just as dismissive as CNIL was when I tried using Right to Erasure with Twitter. I'm under the impression that the ICO only pays lip service to GDPR, and either can't - or won't - actually enforce it because we're no longer in the EU.

meanwhile in the civilized world you write to the webmaster and ask them to change your name because your name has changed and they just do it because why wouldn't they

So suppose you'd changed your name through marriage, as many people do... would they have refused to change it then?

I prefer to not make this the same issue as marriage. Marriage doesn’t usually require a retroactive name change, and in my case, I'm specifically asking them to credit my maiden name, not my married name.

And the simple answer is yes, they'd refuse. They are refusing to change anything they've scraped.

Le soi-disant pays des droits et des libertés portant atteinte à la liberté la plus fondamentale de toutes... le droit de s'autodéfinir.

anyway, angry on your behalf, yes, incredibly so. but surprised? not one bit. france is just as transphobic as the rest.

If I had a claim of my own against SWH I would be jumping at the opportunity to help you, sadly I am not, and I am busy with a different kind of legally angry in French right now, but if the opportunity comes up I'll do whatever I can.

The bit about French being Gender essentialist hits especially hard. My family speaks French primarily. I'm not out as nonbinary to them because i have no way of being addressed or mentioned. Adjectives, verbs, nouns, none of those can be used to describe me accurately in French.

I'm unfortunately probably not going to be able to be out to my family in any meaningful way that i find satisfactory. Because French decided there's only two genders.

Feeling this so hard I can hold it in my hands. Haven't really been out out with my family either because I haven't solved the problem of asking for they/them in French.

Think the literal only reason I'm still officially they/he is just that, the Gendered Language problem, and not wanting to fight an entire language and its resulting perception of all of reality because it really shouldn't be up to me. I actually cringe a bit when I hear a he/him/il/lui... I just bear with it.

The integrity attack makes me so mad. It's much better integrity to update names. Author credits aren't supposed to be a personal history of the author. They're supposed to make it simple to find who authored a work so one could look them up elsewhere.

ugh. I swear I have done both at different times but I will have to check what happened.

but of course, even if the filter-repo didn't stick, that doesn't justify their "why are you hitting yourself" defense

btw now that I've seen it, could you delete the comment?