• She/Her/They/Them

The Scary Trans Streamer Your Parents Warned You About


cathoderaydude
@cathoderaydude
Bovine
@Bovine asked:

Thoughts on iFixIt stuff? I got my screwdrivers from them when I started my CS degree three years ago

So here's the thing, ifixit materialized a long long time ago, and as far as I remember it was quite some time before they started selling tools. When they did, it was in the middle of the big explosion of Maker shenanigans and, long story short, I assumed it was just rollstamped trash, Aliexpress sludge with their name on it, typical swag. ifixit delivers a genuine service, but I had (and continue to have) no idea what their revenue model was, so I assumed they just decided they could bank on their brand recognition to sell some literal garbage.

keeping in mind that the specific things in their toolkits - spudgers, "guitar picks", tiny screwdriver bit sets - were, and are, things that just did not come in a high quality form. they're the sort of thing that can readily be made out of any plastic or alloy that happens to be nearby, no matter how unfit to purpose it is, because most customers either will not notice (because they never get around to actually using it) or will not realize what it means that their "guitar pick" just bent instead of applying force, or their 1/8" PH1 philips bit just turned to goop the third time they tried to use it, or the TPE overmold just peeled off the handle. a lot of people just don't realize how good tools can be if made well, and would not notice that they're just dog shit, and/or would blame themselves.

so, i have to admit: i was astonished by the ifixit stuff. i bought one of their kits a few months ago and, the case openers are made out of the right plastics. the metal spudger is the right kind of stainless. the screwdriver handle doesn't have sharp or flat knurling, it has a goddamn ball bearing I think in the palm cap, it feels good in the hand, it has no stupid TPE overmold, and the bits are not made of cheese.

in addition the bit collection includes a number of things i really like (the little nut drivers, the magnetic pickup bit) which are not commonly included in other kits, and it doesn't include crap just to pad, like security- and non-security versions of torx bits. also, they bothered to machine down the shanks for small bits as far as they could, instead of leaving long pointless hex shafts and then only a little taper at the end, so you have your best chance at getting them into deep recesses.

it doesn't really make sense for ifixit to make a good product but... they seem to. i don't trust it. i'm not sure how to trust it. i've been burned so bad for so long. but in my opinion the kits are a good buy.


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @cathoderaydude's post:

take it with a grain of salt, i haven't reefed on these things too hard, but... it's a feel thing. if a bit is made of cheese, the weight will be wrong, the sheen will be wrong, and you'll feel it give even if you can't see it rounding out. these do not seem to do that.

Thirding the other folks in this thread, I got their screwdriver kit for Christmas and have used it to do several Joycon deconstructs, a switch case swap, deconstruct a dishwasher, and cracked open/cleaned a laptop and all the bits felt like real metal
If these guys are shipping trash I’ve been really lucky with the trash I got

if you're messing about with old game consoles their basic bit set is really useful, i think the only screw i haven't been able to use it for is the T20s in the original xbox but those come out with a regular align key so.

I kinda wonder if you really can build confidence in these tools just by nature of the job they do. Like somebody out there can be confident in replacing an iphone screen or whatever I assume but if I fix something with these tools it will always be by the skin of my teeth.

i wouldn't say i'm anywhere near a Serious Repairs Guy but i love that ifixit toolkit. i use it all the time for basically anything i can and haven't been let down yet. Except for one time i broke the tip off one of the tweezers. But here's the thing: they also sell all those piecemeal so i could get a new one for like $5 and now the set is back to being totally good

I got burned on the little generic "precision screwdriver" kit, and to replace that I got the big IFIXIT bit set. I love the whole construction of it, even the lid functions as a screw sorter in a pinch. It feels like the same people who do their teardowns are the people who vetted the tools.

I've been eyeing their toolkit for a while. I got their tweezer kit when I ordered a replacement PSU for my early 2006 iMac and it's probably the only time i have been impressed by tweezers

I feel like I should also note the Workpro 24-in-1 precision screwdriver, which I think uses the same 4mm profile as iFixit but stores its 12 double bits in an internal carousel. It is inexpensive and very portable and I haven't had a bit explode yet, but it doesn't reach into recesses very well. (edit: the magnets also suck)

going into it, I expected the basic 30-bit ifixit kit to be a hundred and ten dollar tool, only exclusively available online, limited availability, status symbol type repair tool. like you said, it was in the "maker" helldays they got started, and I assumed likewise, it was one of those "specialty boutique Makqueur products" (that's pronounced 'maker' but more European)

I went to microcenter, saw the 64-bit one for $30, and that was the fastest $30 to fly out of my hand. I'm only on my second one because the first was lost in a house fire, and I still don't see myself replacing it anytime soon.

suffice it to say, ifixit seems to give half a shit about the tool, not just the product.
it's the most joy I've had with a "64-bit Driver Kit" since Windows 7.