gonna be mad disappointed if Minthara is made to be available on a "good" playthrough icl. it dilutes her character arc (and i would argue, her romance as well) and makes the game somehow even more problematic in regards to goblins. (to not mention the grossly missed opportunity they already are in relation to the game's repeating theme of cycles of abuse...)
it wouldn't even be a good "fix" for the balance of content because instead of equalizing the two routes it just makes the "evil" one undesirable because now you can just get the evil companion after she got declawed and a pretty bow was slapped on her forehead instead. and the inevitable next step is the same ppl complaining about Lae'zel being rude will now complain that Minthara isn't agreeable to them either 🙄