amagire

Werewolf consultant.

  • they/them, þey/þem

Genderdeer. The meat was paid for, but the bones were stolen.


yrgirlkv
@yrgirlkv

During the Vietnam War, which lasted longer than any war we've ever been in - and which we lost - every respectable artist in this country was against the war. It was like a laser beam. We were all aimed in the same direction. The power of this weapon turns out to be that of a custard pie dropped from a stepladder six feet high.

kurt vonnegut, interview with nuvo news (alt source)


yrgirlkv
@yrgirlkv

when i post quotes i try to keep from adding my own interpretation to them because i don't want to add too much bias; i appreciate hearing alternate reads on a given piece of text. but i'm going to make a small exception this time and say this: i don't read this as saying "resistance is useless." i find it much more useful to read it as "don't mistake art for activism."


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @yrgirlkv's post:

in reply to @yrgirlkv's post:

a good companion quote from Robert Hughes: “It is hard to think of any work of art of which one can say 'this saved the life of one Jew, one Vietnamese, one Cambodian'. Specific books, perhaps; but as far as one can tell, no paintings or sculptures. The difference between us and the artists of the 1920's is that they they thought such a work of art could be made. Perhaps it was a certain naivete that made them think so. But it is certainly our loss that we cannot.”

For five of the seven years of the Vietnam war, the public opinion tended to be against it. To me, this lead to two conclusion:

  1. We can't deduce that art doesn't affect the public from these two facts (that all artist were making art against and that the public opinion was negative). It doesn't mean that it does influence it either, the two could be unrelated. So the result of this study are inconclusive, and we need to look elsewhere.
  2. The fact that the Vietnam war lasted so long despite the public sentiment against it does, to me, speak about the limit of activism. There are some things that are not in our power.