the recent discourse that is, as far as I can tell, about cohost and tumblr having different cultures and vibes is interesting to me, a person of a certain age. I've thought many times that what cohost reminds me of, more than anything, is tumblr circa 2009-2010 -- at least the part of it where a substantial chunk of the userbase was people one to three degrees of separation away from david karp, and a substantial chunk of the discourse there was really just oblique public-facing dispatches from the new york media/gawker/(SORRY LOL) young manhattanite extended universe and its associated backchannels. or like the part of twitter composed primarily of something awful goons who went back 10+ years.
this isn't a value judgment either way, it's just a thought I've had many times
A thing that's kinda wild to me is tumblr users complaining that Cohost has no DMs... when Tumblr didn't have DMs until 2015. Tumblr's whole golden age of posting happened in a DM-less universe.