It's interesting to see people going "hm the fact that there's the Two Fingers and then there's the Three Fingers in Elden Ring seems to imply that at one point they were all one hand, or maybe that they are counterparts to one another or halves of the same coin" and then seeing the counterargument to that be "well hmm if you take the model for the two fingers and the model for the three fingers and you rotate them and mash them together you can see that they don't really fit so I don't think so"
It's just such a... remarkably absurd line of argument. It's not Doylist nor Watsonian but just insane. And yet such is the way people argue about those things that it has as much weight as a much more textually grounded argument.