Hello Cohost, I am soliciting opinions, since Google is useless now.
Considering buying a new pair of headphones to replace my ATH-M50X. I love how they sound but my main pain points are:
- low-quality materials failing, unreplaceably (specifically the earcups, for which you cannot get exact OEM replacements, and the headband, which is not replaceable at all, and has been leaving fragments of black fake-leather shite in my hair for a year now)
- need a 3rd party peripheral (BAL-M50X) for wireless audio, and even though it claims to support low-latency audio through aptX, that is apparently half-cooked or maybe just bullshit
My main usecase is wired, at my desktop computer, fed through a FiiO K3, but I own the BAL-M50X peripheral for a reason, and like having the option to go wireless with my phone or laptop when I'm on the go.
What I'm after, roughly in order of priority:
- high quality materials which mean I won't have to replace the entire thing after owning it for four years
- or at least, like, repairable
- over-the-ear
- and decently roomy
- decently insulated from the outside world (my current pair do this well)
- ...but not heavy enough that I can't wear them for the majority of my day
- wired is good
- wireless is ok if the latency is really low and the battery life is good
- wired/wireless would be ideal
- I am A-OK with plugging in an extra peripheral to my headphones to make them wireless. That's fine. I will buy the peripheral as long as they don't turn the quality to shit
What's unimportant to me:
- active noise cancelling (I have persistent tinnitus and ANC is extremely uncomfortable for me)
- microphone (I like that the BAL-M50X has one that you can plug in, but I have a nice desk mic and I don't often take work calls outside of the house)
- gamer shit
maybe what I'm actually after is headphones for my desk and maybe wireless earbuds for elsewhere??? I don't know! I have been using the same headphones for over a decade (ATH-M50, then ATH-M50X) and I am very open to change.
Man I really did ask for recommendations and then discard all of them... oops.
I ended up ordering the AIAIAI TMA-2 headphones. I opted for the Bluetooth wireless speakers and the Alcantara ear cups, as well as the hard carry case. The order process was pretty painful; the company was initially extremely communicative to my questions but once I placed the order it took weeks to fulfil and I needed to nudge them multiple times to ship it. They were very apologetic and said that it was an unusual case that had somehow slipped through the cracks. I don't know anyone else who owns these so I can't speak to whether it's common.
The headphones themselves are great so far. I've only been using them this evening but I'm already very impressed with how light and comfortable they are without feeling cheap. The Alcantara earcups are perfect for my ear size and hold my head extremely gently. Sound quality is great, they're quite different to the ATH-M50X that they replaced but not in any negative ways. Haven't tested wireless audio quality or the built-in microphones yet. They are not incredibly insulated but, having worn them, I will take lightweight construction over heavy insulation any day.
The process of actually assembling the headphones is really nice, too, though I don't love the amount of packaging they insisted on. They come with each individual component packaged separately, and it all fits together very satisfyingly.
I definitely think I made the right choice with these, but time will tell whether they stand up to, uh, time.
One month in, really liking these still. I've taken a few calls on them, the microphone quality is apparently pretty decent and I love not having to bother with a boom mic. Getting way less head discomfort now too with long sessions due to how light they are. Haven't travelled with them yet but will be roadtripping to Melbourne at the end of the month so I'll get to see how they hold up there.

