I saw Peppermint Bark cookies in the King Arthur newsletter last weekend and have had the recipe open since, planning to bake them soon. Reloaded it today and it went from no reviews to 2.1 stars! Nobody is having a good time with these!
I don't think I should make these, as an only-ok cookie baker. I feel like the safest course is to add crushed peppermint and white chocolate to a double chocolate chip cookie.
I also feel like maybe I'll be the one to have them turn out, since the recipe looks like shortbread (kinda) and I've been making that since I was 5.
Do I gamble??