g.d.

ALL TIME

1. Lionblaze
2. Blackstar
3. Sol
4. Clawface
5. Mudclaw
6. Runningnose
7. Goosefeather
8. Hawkfrost
9. Whitethroat
10. Harestar
    thunderclan: 2
    shadowclan: 4
    riverclan: 1
    windclan: 2
    outsider: 1

note: for the arc-specific ones, I'm ranking them based on their personality/actions in THAT ARC ALONE. so all-time favourites who were active in several arcs may not be in the same ranking or on the list at all, if I only started liking them later

THE PROPHECIES BEGIN

1. Nightstar
2. Runningnose
3. Cinderpelt
4. Ravenpaw
5. Whitethroat
6. Littlecloud
7. Ashfur (ShadowClan)
8. Brightheart
9. Tigerstar I
10. Boulder

thunderclan: 3
shadowclan: 7

THE NEW PROPHECY

1. Hawkfrost
2. Mudclaw
3. Blackstar
4. Tawnypelt
5. Purdy
6. Stormfur
7. Mothwing
8. Russetfur
9. Cinderpelt
10. Daisy

thunderclan: 2
shadowclan: 3
riverclan: 3
windclan: 1
outsider: 1

POWER OF THREE

1. Lionblaze
2. Sol
3. Blackstar
4. Heathertail
5. Fallen Leaves
6. Russetfur
7. Brightheart
8. Longtail
9. Snowbird
10. Dawnpelt

thunderclan: 3
shadowclan: 4
windclan: 1
outsider: 2

OMEN OF THE STARS

1. Lionblaze
2. Blackstar
3. Breezepelt
4. Beetlewhisker
5. Briarlight
6. Ivypool
7. Flametail
8. Antpelt
9. Snowbird
10. Mousewhisker

thunderclan: 4
shadowclan: 3
riverclan: 1
windclan: 2

DAWN OF THE CLANS

1. Clear Sky
2. One Eye
3. Pebble Heart
4. Holly
5. Tall Shadow
6. Acorn Fur
7. Star Flower
8. Jagged Peak
9. Moon Shadow
10. Grey Wing

A VISION OF SHADOWS

1. Harestar
2. Darktail
3. Rain
4. Puddleshine
5. Waspwhisker
6. Tree
7. Crowfrost
8. Flywhisker
9. Ivypool
10. Briarlight

thunderclan: 3
shadowclan: 2
windclan: 1
skyclan: 2
outsider: 2

THE BROKEN CODE

1. Snowtuft
2. Silverhawk
3. Tigerstar II
4. Juniperclaw
5. Shadowsight
6. Spotfur
7. Bristlefrost
8. Lionblaze
9. Tree
10. Puddleshine

thunderclan: 3
shadowclan: 6 (I count Silverhawk as ShadowClan bc of my fanfiction lol sorrynotsorry)
skyclan: 1

ShadowClan: 41%
ThunderClan: 29%
WindClan: 10%
Outsider: 9%
RiverClan: 7%
SkyClan: 4%