I finally got the opportunity to try some of the Girl Scout cookies from the other factory, since my husband and I ordered from a couple of the trans scouts on this list. I've been keen on trying the sandwich-style s'mores cookies (the """s'mores""" cookies that we had in our region were godawful) and i can confirm that the sandwich ones are fucking delicious. I have a hell of a sweet tooth, and decimated that package over the course of less than 48 hours. I regret not getting another package or two.
I also think the lemon-ups are better than the lemonades; they're crispier and have a more citrus-y lemon flavor, compared with the creamier lemon flavor of lemonades. Both are good, though.
The brownie baker thin mints are also lighter and have more of a dry crumble bordering on flakiness. The mint flavor is gentler than the other thin mints? It's a bit difficult to describe. I enjoy both versions just fine.
As always, I'm terribly nostalgic for the piñata cookies that had such a short lifespan years ago. I haven't found any ripoffs that taste similar enough to serve as a substitution.