jkap

CEO of posting

butch jewish dyke
part of @staff, cohost user #1
married to @kadybat

This user can say it
osu stats


🐘 mastodon
xoxo.zone/@jkap
🖼️ icon credit
twitter.com/osmoru
🐦 twitter
not anymore lol

no one has any idea what they actually want to be anymore. they just want to feed off twitter’s corpse.

tiktok and instagram both have over 1 billion MAU. what do they have to gain by adding text-based social media? do they think their market is saturated? is this how they Grow? is infinite growth actually possible? (it isn’t.)

tumblr is, by their own admission, pretty deep in the hole, but they’re approaching that problem by changing so much of what makes their platform distinct and alienating their longtime users in the process, all while continuing to make major, prominent fuck ups in moderation.

twitter’s collapse has left a giant hole in the market that everyone is desperate to fill but can’t figure out how. the benefit of twitter was that it was fucking huge and everyone was on it. it is likely impossible to replicate that, so how do you actually get users?

there is value in knowing what you actually offer. a lot of the current big players seem confused about that. but maybe when you have seemingly infinite money and a ton of employees you can just try shit with the expectation it won’t work. i wouldn’t know.


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @jkap's post:

I think it's just the same idea as Twitter was trying to do before Musk-implosion: Getting people to never leave their platform ever.
Honestly I do really appreciate Youtube's community posts (which unfortunately are locked only to monetized channels), so I think there's a good reasons to add text posts to video platforms, but Tiktoks seem to be kinda replacing their videos instead of being in a separate place for a separate use...... which is weird

It's just capitalism, have the most of the things at any cost as long as it makes money. Doesn't matter if you sacrifice yourself to be an inferior copy of a place and lose whatever made your place work in the first place along with your original userbase with nobody to replace them, everyone else is and you don't want to be left out do you?

tiktok and instagram both have over 1 billion MAU. what do they have to gain by adding text-based social media? do they think their market is saturated? is this how they Grow? is infinite growth actually possible?

so the big thing that sticks out to me is that twitter only had 300 million MAU at its peak; I don't think any of these companies would be going out of their way to replace it solely for growth. I think at the root of all this has to be some acknowledgement from facebook and bytedance that despite being more popular, their offerings are missing something fundamental -- something that, by its absence, will cause the whole enterprise of social media to collapse, or that at the very least they need to prevent from falling into a competitor's hands

It's an interesting idea that Twitter's absence could cause broader problems. Twitter has always punched above its weight class in terms of relevancy and some of that is just intangible and some of it is just the way this specific platform shaped the news in a way Facebook only ever dreamed of. It's almost a prestige product more than anything else, or at least it was.

There are two big mistakes being made here imo. One is failing to recognize that at its peak twitter's monthly user numbers were around the same size as Pinterest's (a very small pie to fight over), and two I think these companies assume that microblogging as a "mass" social networking method will absolutely outlive twitter.

Microblogging as a semi popular concept can die and diminish to a niche subset of the internet like any number of things that have come before it, and it's frankly what I expect to happen here.

It's really unnerving to see most of these platforms throw everything into new gimmicks and social features at the cost of user experience and stability; all for the chance of maybe getting a few more users. Users who, already burnt out from Twitters garbage pile, will see these Pointless new gimmicks and reckless abandonment of their core values as an eerie similarity to twitters behavior.

I really wish these platforms would stick to what they're good at and not look like a bloated whale trying to suck a whole cooked turkey through a crazy straw.