no description only meoww


iliana
@iliana

i think my main takeaway from Nix/Nixpkgs/NixOS is that the more you learn about it and the ecosystem around it, the faster you oscillate between "this is cool" and "lol this sucks". you never stop oscillating between these two absolutes.


leftpaddotpy
@leftpaddotpy

nix rules because you can fix her

nix fucking sucks because you can fix her and nobody else did it yet



bruno
@bruno

Also like... you are not immune to propaganda so I would caution to consider whether your 'nuanced argument' is not just an OpenAI talking point in disguise.

Specifically I'm talking about arguments about 'intelligence.' Now intelligence is a slippery and ill-defined term, but I've seen people whom I'd hope are well intentioned talk about the "emergent behavior" of LLMs and suggest that that's a kind of "intelligence."

This is very much the Sam Altman position – 'intelligence' is a kind of spectrum, with 'strong' 'general artificial intelligence' on one end, LLMs on the other, and humans somewhere in between.

But the thing you're meant to believe from hearing this argument is that if only they can pump even more precious resources into an LLM, it will eventually become 'more intelligent'. And that's... simply not true. What an LLM is doing is just qualitatively different from what a human mind is doing. You can call that 'intelligence' if you want, I guess, but that's extremely misleading.

Or, to put it another way: you can say that I can cook, and you can say that a microwave oven can cook, but those are wildly different definitions of what 'cooking' means; and no advance in microwave technology can make it capable of producing, say, a caesar salad.

Ultimately OpenAI wants 'intelligence' to be a singular, obviously measurable thing, and they want you to believe that their product can be said to possess that thing. This is both an inaccurate view of the world and a harmful one; people seem to very easily miss how bound up in colonialist and racist thinking the AI boosters' view of 'intelligence' is.

Above all, it's extremely easy to be credulous about LLMs because the technology is frankly intended to trick people. The tech itself is propaganda for the tech. LLMs generate text that's statistically likely, that resembles 'real' text written by someone; that's the trick. It is of course very difficult to tell a statistical average apart from the real thing, except in various ways that really matter when the rubber meets the road.

Pumping more electricity into these data centers and munging more text is not going to produce something that has the qualitatively different capabilities that a human mind has. This is like saying "cars are getting faster all the time so soon they'll be able to fly." Or thinking that VR headsets getting better will lead, merely through incremental improvement, to full dive experiences that are indistinguishable from real life.


leftpaddotpy
@leftpaddotpy

i don't have anywhere im going with this thought, it just smells really bad.

although, is seeing simplistically in the manner of a state any different from colonialism? :p



iliana
@iliana

i think my main takeaway from Nix/Nixpkgs/NixOS is that the more you learn about it and the ecosystem around it, the faster you oscillate between "this is cool" and "lol this sucks". you never stop oscillating between these two absolutes.


iliana
@iliana

anyway if any nix touchers out there use a deployment tool they actually like, even if you wrote it yourself, please let me know. i am evaluating options for replacing my bad python script


leftpaddotpy
@leftpaddotpy

for most people nixos-rebuild with the target host option is sufficient.

if it is not and you want to build one, it should probably use nix-eval-jobs. i think some people like colmena, but I've not tried it because i am among those for whom nixos-rebuild is totally sufficient, even as someone who does cross compiled machines and tiny machines sometimes.




ireneista
@ireneista

rather than by the fabric per se, since the amount of fabric only goes up with the square of the length


leftpaddotpy
@leftpaddotpy

also hajar are so fucking expensive, there's literally been 50% sharkflation since 2019 :(

and the smolhaj is 8 euros or something and 20 cad. grrrrr

i swear i might bring back some haj (again) when i go to Europe.