Ever since making that post about stopping doing live-commentary let's play, almost giving myself permission to stop, my IDEA BRAIN had been PREGNANT with ideas of how a post-commentary thing would work! If you'll indulge me POSTING my ideas here.
I'm immediately thinking about the post-com being based around the model I'm using, focusing on their specific interest in the game? So on-top of general commentary about enjoying the game, for example Ell who plays games about "Little guys" (monster catcher and pet simulator games) would take a moment from the gameplay to rate the little guys. Red the character who plays "Gun-horny Games" (general catch all for FPS and games like post RE4 Resi) can do a little section on how the Gun Horny Do. Or Sleet who plays mystery and adventure games can criticise and rate the detective he's playing as.
Cos in LPing I had to think of the vibes I'm going for. I want an in-between a live-commentary and longplay? The game will mostly speak for itself, but with just me chiming in with stuff every now and then. I do not have an example of what I'm shooting for so I guess we're experimenting! haha