mcc

glitch girl

Avatar by @girlfiend

Also on Bluesky
Also on Mastodon.


So I have been learning the Castlevania: Symphony of the Night speedrun on Christine's XBox Series X and I was gonna stream it this weekend. On Playstation streaming direct from the console was incredibly easy so I expected it would be simple on XBox also.

It is not. So: I tell it to start streaming. It does everything on screen to show it has started streaming. When I bring up the stream on Twitch, it's… a silent loop of… a "corporate Memphis" animation of an astronaut and an angel and a cat clock.¹ It is supposed to be Castlevania Symphony of the Night. Certain system menus, if I bring them up while this is happening, force the stream to automatically "pause" and once it pauses it does not (can not) unpause, the streaming UI is just locked up. I can click "Unpause stream" and it bleeps and animates like I selected the menu item but the menu option continues to show "Unpause stream" afterward and the stream remains "paused". Of course, I'm not sure what difference this makes since it streams the same cat clock animation regardless of whether it's "paused" or "unpaused". In any of these situations, my headphone sound is not included.

This is really hard to chase down because how do you even search for that? "Stream is a cat clock." What I eventually find is a five year old Reddit thread where it turns out you simply can't stream Symphony of the Night. More specifically the XBox does not let you stream ANYTHING unless the developer has set a special "ok to stream" flag, and none of the XBox 360 backward compatibility titles have the flag set at all. So that's really disappointing, but beyond that, why not show some kind of error message in that case? Why… just stream something totally other?

Not sure if I'm going to be able to make my stream tomorrow work or not. :/

¹ A friend tells me he recognizes this as one of the animations from Microsoft's "Mixer" service?!

EDIT: Story continues


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @mcc's post:

I get constantly notified on my PS5 that various cutscenes are not available for streaming, even though, to my knowledge, I am not streaming, I have never set up streaming, etc. But yeah, doing this is a new one on me rofl

The error message thing is symptomatic of UX design philosophy from at least 2008, when UX designers, in designing error screens, wanted to move away from Windows 95-style blue screens, which they felt users had been interpreting as unfriendly and too technically daunting. The problem with this is twofold: not only do the new error messages fail to convey the level of useful information that Windows 95 error screens provided (there were error codes to look up), but the language that designers have replaced it with reminds users too much of customer service speak that only pretends to be friendly and helpful more for the sake of the speaker than the person they're speaking with. In other words, it's just as unfriendly as what it replaced; just in a different direction.

god mixer was so good for 9 months, it was the best streaming service, then microsoft bought it and ate it all up and made it pointless.

it had nearly latency free streaming! built in interaction with viewers, like putting buttons directly on their screens! a healthy community! everything i want from streaming!

anyway this just reminded me that mixer was good and now it's microsoft

MS actually shut Mixer down after buying it :( In like July 2020. It was really abrupt and seemed to be in direct response to a single scandal where someone went public about racism on the Mixer team. Instead of trying to fix the corporate culture they just shut down the entire product within days of the negative press appearing.

They transferred all the Mixer partners of the time to, of all places, Facebook Gaming.