Sandwich Imagineer at Twinbeard. Made Frog Fractions. May or may not have already made Frog Fractions 2 through 5.


That arrangement sounds like this:

You can see the glass harmonica in the background at 1:13. It's the one that sounds like when you rub the rim of a wine glass. You can most notably hear it, but not see it, during its big moment at 1:55, because the glass harmonica is an obscure instrument and probably the people filming didn't know why this old guy operating a lathe is also in the room with all the attractive kids playing instruments we've heard of.

Usually The Aquarium is performed by an orchestra-sized string section, with glockenspiel substituting for the glass harmonica:

I'd heard stories about an apocryphal recording where the producers wanted to create a performance more authentic to the original arrangement, but accidentally hired "harmonica virtuoso Tommy Reilly" instead of a glass harmonica player. ("Harmonica virtuoso Tommy Reilly" is the only specific ever provided by these stories.) I don't think anyone's ever done the legwork to properly substantiate this story, but the version of The Aquarium on the Burnout Paradise soundtrack sure sounds like it might be the one:

What are the chances that this is a coincidence? That there are multiple recordings of The Aquarium that made this mistake? In my headcanon, it happens all the time. Every night, Tommy Reilly heads into a different recording studio, plays that pair of glissandos, then squawks "it's a living!"


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @mogwai-poet's post:

This is the 1961 recording with Tommy Reilly. (I'm also sure I saw that cover art linked to the version on Burnout Paradise, but can't seem to find the URL in my history that had it.)

Given that a lot of the stories involve a "1990s Slovenian orchestra". It's quite likely the origin story is completely made up.

I've seen comments that this was in fact a deliberate choice, not a mistake. I couldn't find any confirmation of this, but without any further confirmation I'd work on the assumption this is correct.

According to Tommy Reilly's wikipedia page, at that time he "...worked with many composers to get more original music written for the instrument." If there was a mistake confusing the two instruments, it's just as plausible it was from Reilly's own promotion of the harmonica.