R. Yirmeya raises the "worst halakhic question" of all time, is immediately asked to leave the yeshiva
according to Wikipedia this guy had a whole villain and redemption arc around this:
He frequently provoked the laughter of the academy, except of his teacher;[10] and ultimately his ultra-subtleties became insufferable. His considerate preceptor time and again warned him against pursuing his arguments beyond the bounds of halakhah;[11] but it proved of no avail. At last his colleagues gave vent to their displeasure. The college was seriously discussing a point of law, when Jeremiah broke in with what appeared to be a ridiculous objection, whereupon he was ordered out of the academy.[12] It happened that after the death of the great teachers a legal problem vexed the minds of the scholars, and there was none to solve it. It was submitted to Jeremiah, who returned it with the solution, which he prefaced with the humble words: "Although I am not worthy [to be consulted by you], your pupil's opinion inclines this way." On receipt of this, which was taken as an apology for the past, his colleagues reinstated him.[13]
We found the OG "Yet you participate in society. Curious!" guy
