pendell

Current Hyperfixation: Wizard of Oz

  • He/Him

I use outdated technology just for fun, listen to crappy music, and watch a lot of horror movies. Expect posts about These Things. I talk a lot.

Check tags like Star Trek Archive and Media Piracy to find things I share for others.



Gene Roddenberry was an ideas guy, not a writing guy. It was very forward-thinking of him to suggest that mental health would be important enough in the future for a ship's counselor to have equal importance to the ship's first officer, with their own seat on the bridge next to the captain.

But then he never fleshed the idea out any further, the "ship's counselor" was never given any real job, and by the time the other writers realized the problem, presumably everything about how the Enterprise-D crew would operate was already set in stone, so now we have Deanna Troi, ship's counselor, who's going to be in pretty much every single episode, always there, who has basically nothing to do unless the episode is explicitly about Her. Hell, her mother, the occasional side character, is far more interesting than she's ever allowed to be.

Like yeah, Picard wasn't able to leave the bridge or the ship that often because of his importance bla bla bla, but Troi probably spent 90% of her screentime sitting quietly in a chair, with the occasional cut to her with a Concerned Face to remind you she exists. She's as much set dressing as Michael Okuda's LCARS panels.


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @pendell's post:

Ironically, probably a lot of what a ship’s counsellor would do is deal with interpersonal conflict among the crew if Roddenberry hadn’t also decided that humanity had evolved past that.

As I've been going through the series, I feel like it's far worse than that. When "counseling," she either operates from a place of loyalty to Picard (which is shockingly realistic) or dismisses the problem. But her real job seems to be to help the crew manipulate any aliens who the ship finds.

My favorite incident, though, is Contagion, where she tells Riker to give the crew some task to focus on instead of their impending doom, and they agree that the best task is planning to evacuate the ship. Yep, that'll keep their mind off the danger...

I know this comment is 11 months old but I was looking through all my posts tagged "Star Trek" and man... it's really funny when in The Drumhead the bad lady has a betazoid assistant who she uses for accusatory purposes, and when Picard confronts her about it she's like "well, don't you use your betazoid for a strategic advantage when dealing with other ships?" He has no real response besides "well... yeah but when we do it it's different" and if memory serves he never really articulates why it's any different. It just Is, because Picard is the Good Guy!

That's such a brilliant move in the writing, especially since the episode starts with Troi interrogating the Klingon visitor while the actual chief of security whose job this should be just stands quietly in the corner with his arms crossed. But he sputters about how he'd never have her lead the investigation and just take her word for it. I also had to appreciate that they set her origins in Conspiracy, the episode where Picard pats himself on the back for murdering a bunch of colleagues because he suspects them of foreign influence.

Specific to Troi, it's also fun when they try to show her actually conducting therapy sessions, because they'll often mention that she's everyone's counselor, which gets back to your point of how it's progressive that she's there at all, but it's clear that nobody takes her job seriously. Even she doesn't. I think that it's The Loss, where she gives the big speech about how, without her powers forcing her to understand what people feel, she couldn't care less about any of their problems!