pendell

Current Hyperfixation: Wizard of Oz

  • He/Him

I use outdated technology just for fun, listen to crappy music, and watch a lot of horror movies. Expect posts about These Things. I talk a lot.

Check tags like Star Trek Archive and Media Piracy to find things I share for others.



I find it really funny that TNG insists Data doesn't experience or understand emotions (until he gets that emotion chip way later on) but it's so extremely obvious that he does, just not in the traditional sense. He clearly experiences joy, wonder, sadness, internal conflict, confusion, desire, etc. throughout the show.

Data ain't emotionless he's just an autistic man! And when you look at it that way it makes the way everyone treats him and how he's singled out as "odd" and "other" feel really sad. Nobody can really connect with him through usual means. He finds it difficult or impossible to emotionally relate to his crewmates, and spends a good chunk of his character-focused episodes trying to wrap his mind around the neurotypical experience. But they all still do their best to treat him with respect.

To that end, Measure of a Man is the episode where Autism Speaks shows up to study the autistic man and deprive him of his basic rights.


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @pendell's post:

I've been re-watching the series for my blog specifically for issues like this, and it's really striking how awful the crew is to each other. Data keeps outright asking people for help feeling included and winning basic respect from his peers, and instead they remind him that he doesn't belong or laugh at him.

But it's not just Data. They're pretty terrible to all the non-humans, women, and non-white humans, for at least the first few years. They think that therapy is for manipulating negotiations instead of dealing with emotional issues. And don't forget the military coup because a handful of old people are worried about foreign influence...

Gene Roddenberry fought tooth and nail for control over that show until he croaked. His death was, honestly, the best thing that could happened to TNG. It allowed to show to escape the shadow of the 1960s, and truly be the next generation.

I sometimes wonder, though, how much of that history was written by his successors, because the early years of TNG are almost the opposite perspective from the original series. Granted, Roddenberry was also twenty years older and a lot wealthier, so maybe that conservatism came from him, but it's bizarre that people at the time imagined Kirk as some womanizing brawler, when he's very much not that, and Picard got immediate credit as a considerate thinker when he asks Data for information just to cut him off...

Which is neither here nor there, I guess.

The fact that most episodes of TOS are more progressive than TNG Season 1 episodes like the dreaded "Code of Honor" or the ill-advised "Angel One" is wild to me. TNG definitely stumbled out of the gate.