• he/him

massachusetts

see Carrd link for forwarding information



tbf I think children's history education has significantly improved since the 90s and they're not being taught exactly the way I was

...well, in Massachusetts they probably aren't. I assume in Florida and Texas they're learning that Christopher Colombus was the greatest supergenius of all time and could read minds and levitate

update: some brief googling of variations on "Christopher Columbus lesson plan" suggests the teaching is still kinda all over the place, from "CC was a bastard, we celebrate Indigenous People's Day" to "teach the controversy" to this particularly ripe one that calls him "America's Founder" and encourages kids to venerate the statue of Christopher Columbus and has the nerve to call it a "primary source"

update2: oh my fucking GOD the Florida Christopher Columbus curriculum is literally PragerU. YouTube link that you may want to open in incognito, or not open ever. I'm honestly not even sure how well this works as propaganda because it feels so... mid-argument? in the way a lot of conservative stuff does. like it's not really teaching the story from the top, it's just throwing stuff like "oh yeah well do you think white people were the only enslavers around?" at invisible Twitter opponents.

also it is wrong about a lot of basic undisputed facts like how long the trip was. and gets in more digs at Muslims than you would think possible in a video about an almost completely unrelated subject. and for some reason refers to the ancient Greeks as "permitting lifestyles" he didn't approve of, which I get as a dogwhistle for "gay" but it's the weirdest fucking way to talk about ancient Greece where the sexuality situation was uhhh NOT "a minority of adult men like to have consensual relationships with each other and the rest of us tolerate them"

update3: the Texas Columbus curriculum is more "normal," like it's certainly not addressing the atrocities but it's more like the "yay exploring the world!" version I got in the 90s than like PragerU taking weird side shots at everything conservatives are mad about. actually it's kinda written like there wasn't anybody in the land he "discovered," all it says is that the Bahamas "had riches that Columbus could take back to Spain," like, I guess just lying on the ground


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @pervocracy's post:

I can't decide if Trump started it, or just brought it into focus and made it worse, but that "and another thing, concerning my haters and liars," rhetorical flourish boils my piss and it's everywhere

it just seems wildly offputting to anyone who doesn't already know what you're on about

unless their parents are particularly committed chuds, first graders aren't going to have a context for this, they're just going to be like dang, Chris Columbus had a lot of weird beef to settle with hypothetical blue haired children apparently

In Massachusetts in the 90's, either they were teaching small children a Typical Propadanda but with an asterix about Bad Things also happening, and older children the Chris Columbus was a bastard version. Or it was a time of fairly fast change in how they were teaching it. Unsure which, because I experienced the early 90's as a tiny gradeschooler and the late 90's as a highschool student.
I def. knew about the world circumference thing by 5th grade though.

I started 1st grade in 1989 πŸ˜…
Come to think of it once we got to late elementary school this may have been a "put the textbook away, have this stack of blury photocopies instead" Social Studies unit. Also thinking about it with adult eyes in retrospect I think they may have been sort of flailing around building a curriculum which weighs in heavily for "rapid change, spread unevenly across school districts."

i grew up in florida in the 90s, and we had multiple dedicated semesters to learning about the holocaust once you got to a certain grade level including a field trip to the holocaust museum to really hammer home how fucking bad it was, and the experience will never leave me. i think it started in 8th grade, and continued into high school. i'm afraid to even look at what happened to that curriculum in present day, if it even still exists given the state of things over there now. 😬