this is very long lsdfkj
- Battlefield 1
looks phenomenal, runs flawlessly and is hands-down the best war shooter ive played in years from a presentation standpoint alone. 1's gunplay and pacing feels like an action film from start to finish, with good variety in mission design and large, destructible battlefields that sell the setting well alongside melancholic writing. for singleplayer it's the only one i recommend wholeheartedly, the one drawback being the very short length at 4 hours. a tight runtime but im left wanting more.
Best Level: Through Mud And Blood
great mix of tank battles, on-foot firefights and a decent if cliche squad story to keep things relatively engaging. loved the nighttime look of the second stage and harried fighting throughout; the perfect introduction to BF1's mechanics.
Worst Level: Avanti Savoia
way too brief and not much more than 20 minutes of running across fields, gunning everything that moves. BF1's fluid combat is enough to hold this simplicity afloat but compared to the other chapters, it's too little.
- Battlefield V
essentially 1 but shorter, harder, more gimmicky and less fresh. probably the closest thing to a modern expansion pack minus the pricing. there's a couple minor tweaks that build on 1's strong foundation, some i like (more ammo drops and vastly lower player TTK creates more chaos) and some i don't (medics that revive enemies and annoying sniper nerfs do the opposite). you're basically getting more of the same but with 100% more nazis to murder and slightly worse cohesion in presentation. still recommended if you want more of BF1's gameplay.
Best Level: Tirailleur
a brutal set of massive battlefield fights, strewn across beautiful autumnal landscapes. requires every skill learned and is paired with a surprisingly effective bit of writing addressing racial prejudice. best of the whole series.
Worst Level: Nordlys
stealth? in Battlefield? with nothing more than line-of-sight that immediately alerts every soldier in Norway when spotted? kindly fuck off and leave those shallow mechanics back in the early 2000s, i got enough of that from Medal Of Honour.
- Battlefield 4
torn on this one. BF4 is a tech demo that surpasses all blandness through sheer technical wizardry. barely. i couldn't name a level, character or plot beat if held at gunpoint but i was constantly impressed at just how malleable each environment was, even moreso than the above. every building explodes, every obstacle can be shot, every fight ends up levelling the neighbourhood and despite the most forgettable writing this side of a bad Modern Warfare and bugs up the arse, it's worth a trip to see the spectacle.
Best Level: Tashgar
one giant playground of houses, tanks, every kind of soldier and you. loads of fun running around like a headless chicken and tackling whatever jumps in front. not the strongest all-round Battlefield level but definitely a showcase of what Frostbite can do.
Worst Level: South China Sea
basically a bunch of tiny boring corridors in ships combined with some seriously bad glitches. have fun taking 10 minutes to swim through five meters of water and witnessing half the ship turn on noclip.
THE POSITIVES STOP NOW
- Battlefield 3
take all the qualities of 4, lessen them considerably and support them with nothing else. that's Battlefield 3. mediocre all the way through with small flashes of interesting ideas that its sequel would improve on, feeling like it was tossed together at the last minute. i remember nothing from this game and i played it three days ago, it's the most functional, threadbare military shooter with little to offer beyond audiovisual polish. utterly forgettable; a multiplayer tutorial in all but name.
Best Level: Nightshift
honestly, i only remember it for being the sniper stage. yknow, up on a building at night, shooting at guys miles away? you've played shooters before. really only sticks out for being a decent rendition of the formula and having some nice lighting.
Worst Level: Rock And A Hard Place
it's a generic fight across some small field, like all of 3, but has some rubbish setpieces. Battlefield's uniquely organic fights suck when paired with scripted sequences involving specific movement, i had a hell of a time just figuring out where to go without instantly dying and having my teammates push me out of cover. rancid combination, please don't do COD.
- Battlefield Hardline
what a misbegotten, bizarre spinoff. this didn't need to exist, simply put. none of Battlefield's strengths, all its shortcomings, wrapped up in a wannabe-Payday/SWAT clone that refuses to commit to either. i don't know why they decided repetitive mini-brawls in tiny urban environments was a good idea, nor the introduction of pacifist mechanics that go against the series DNA it's still using.
make arrests to unlock more guns? what?
add to this some weak police Miami Vice garbage with the gall to pull some "not all cops" shit and this one's for the trashfire. don't bother, play Payday 2 instead.
Best Level: Legacy
i mean it's the only open level here. that's... idk that's something. hey look, Battlefield, thank god, i can almost forget the three hours of an identity crisis.
Worst Level: The Rest Of Them But Also Gator Bait
i didn't like any of Hardline really but the second level is fucking boring. a solid 40 minutes of slowly driving a boat in the swamp while Cop #4 regales you with details about some drug crime or something idk, i stopped caring. occasionally you shoot a gun. when the game feels like it. gripping stuff.