Not sure what this is. It's not Edith Wharton. It's maybe trying to be Bridgerton, with all the same problems that Bridgerton has with erasing Britain's colonial history - a history which in structural terms, still affects every person of colour living in this country today. It's anachronistic, in some ways that I can appreciate, but also in other ways that (again) feel like they flatten out parts of British history or culture. The writing veers wildly around in tone, one minute trying to be wry and acidic (trying for Wharton, maybe?), the next somber or dramatic (but actually just... really dull), the next being incredibly twee with dialogue riddled with sub-Whendonesque verbal tics. It's irritating, and I think it doesn't do many favours to the actors, who I suspect are probably better individually than they are as a group given these lines to speak, given this direction, given this cinematography.
I'm two episdoes in and wondering if this is going to get better in future episodes. Edith Wharton was very good at writing about class, culture, repression, unhappy marriages, people caught between duty and personal longings they can't square with the societies they're in. In theory, this series is touching on similar themes. But... Everything is so flattened out, which Wharton doesn't do. Where's the depth? Why these clunky lines that don't sound like Wharton, don't sound like speech of the time, but also don't sound like how actual people speak today? Why this particular vision of England that pretends to say something about class and repression, but says nothing at all about how that intersects with constructions of race or colonialism?
I think none of this feels real to me, either emotionally or intellectually because it's... Well, it's shallow, and not in a good way. Why bother to base yourself on Edith Wharton if this is what you make? If you're doing your own original story and characters, then... It's still probably going to be dreadfully shallow, but I wouldn't be sat here comparing it to Wharton at least. It's never going to stand up well to that comparison.