shel

The Transsexual Chofetz Chaim

Mutant, librarian, poet, union rabble rouser, dog, Ashkenazi Jewish. Neuroweird, bodyweird, mostly sleepy.


I write about transformative justice, community, love, Judaism, Neurodivergence, mental health, Disability, geography, rivers, labor, and libraries; through poetry, opinionated essays, and short fiction.


I review Schoolhouse Rock! songs at @PropagandaRock


Website (RSS + Newsletter)
shelraphen.com/

pervocracy
@pervocracy

started watching the Doctor Who special and got as far as "I would burn down the world for you, darling" and I'll let you know how the rest of it is if I ever stop crying


pervocracy
@pervocracy

okay, I finished The Star Beast and you know what this is? I think it's post-cringe.

I mean, not that Doctor Who of all shows has ever shied away from cringe, but this feels... conscious. Feels like a decision was made to say fuck you, this is a goofy sappy rocketship show and we aren't too cool for primary colors and googly-eyed rubber monsters and multiple passionate speeches about Love.

Could the trans acceptance stuff have been more subtle? Yeah, and isn't it fucking awesome that it's not? They had the opportunity to do a "just happens to be trans" and instead they said "if you were Donna Noble's nonbinary trans daughter she would hug you and love you and fight for you and tell everyone how lucky she is to have you."

...

anyway, two more episodes until David Tennant inevitably has to die again and cries directly into the camera about it for, lowball estimate, forty-five solid minutes


pervocracy
@pervocracy

Thinking about it more and I know I'm reading a lot into a silly nerd show and giving it extra points for the fact that I already liked it

but I feel like it's really powerful that its key argument for trans rights is... just love. Not theory, not politics, not even justice as most people would understand the term, not begging for understanding and making a case. Just showing a family that already loves their trans daughter, that always has, with absolutely no air spared for a balanced debate about whether she deserves to be loved.

and a lot of the reason this special hit me like a train of bricks was that I'm a debate kid, I'm terminally online, I'm Jewish... I'm real easy to bait into a philosophical argument about why it's logical to end the violent enforcement of Gender. so it's really good to see something that's extremely mainstream (and British!) and produced by cis people going no, actually, we're not going to have this conversation, we are simply going to model respect and care and love.


@shel shared with:

You must log in to comment.

in reply to @pervocracy's post:

I didn't even know it was already a thing but all the trans doctor who fans are happy and all the cis doctor who fans are "I just have some notes" so I guess I have to watch it too

Legally Streamed Of Course

cries directly into the camera about it for, lowball estimate, forty-five solid minutes

(he's right and he should say it)

I feel like BBC (the public broadcasting company of TERF Island ruled by the Conservative Party) and Disney (notorious homophobes and censors of queer content) approached Russel T. Davies and said "Hi we want to give Doctor Who back to you with a huge budget will you please come back and run Doctor Who again you're the fan favorite we need your pull"

and he went "You two conservative companies want me, acclaimed writer of Queer As Folk, to come back and write Doctor Who again? Well.... :) OK" and then just used the full budget to scream TRANS RIGHTS as unapologetically as possible and I loved it so so so much more than I ever would have thought I would.

I also loved the fact that it was deeply plot relevant?! Like, you couldn't make any minority characters into a majority character and have the plot still work. The one UNIT officer not affected by the mind control isn't affected because she can't use the stairs and that allows her to use her ROCKET WHEELCHAIR in a pivotal moment. Rose choosing the name Rose was DEEPLY important for the twist. Ohhhh it was SO good