shel

The Transsexual Chofetz Chaim

Mutant, librarian, poet, union rabble rouser, dog, Ashkenazi Jewish. Neuroweird, bodyweird, mostly sleepy.


I write about transformative justice, community, love, Judaism, Neurodivergence, mental health, Disability, geography, rivers, labor, and libraries; through poetry, opinionated essays, and short fiction.


I review Schoolhouse Rock! songs at @PropagandaRock


Website (RSS + Newsletter)
shelraphen.com/

It feels like Something to me that cis women doing makeup tutorials always use gender neutral phrases like “this just helps me feel more like a human being” or “it just makes me feel like I look more like a contributing member of society” while trans women doing makeup tutorials generally just say “It makes me feel more like a woman—I mean I already am one but you know just more feminine less dysphoric and all that”

They’re ultimately getting at exactly the same feelings aren’t they? The cis women in these videos are saying they feel inhuman until they get dolled up by doing an elaborate painting on their face. They often won’t even show an actual bare face without makeup at the beginning and if they do they bemoan how terrible they feel looking at their own face without makeup. It’s dysphoria! They see themselves in the mirror and feel so gross they don’t even feel like a human being equal to other people in their own life until they use thirty different products to perfectly give themselves a new face of their own creative design. Their makeupsona. Their chosen face.

Because the cis women feel more confident that they’re already women inherently they express their insecurities in a gender neutral manner. “I feel like a gross feral squirrel” or something. Whereas trans women are more insecure in their womanhood and frame it as not being woman enough. But it’s the same feeling ain’t it?


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @shel's post:

i feel like a lot of gender stuff has to do with some sort of relationship to empathy. so because of this i feel like some gender-related fixation on cuteness is connected to like "oh shit i could be someone precious, someone to care about and take care of and adore and so on".

i think thats why it feels like pretty often with high fem queers you may see them go more high fem early on than what they settle with longterm, because they're pursuing that sort of feeling so hard because its not something they're used to having. this comes to mind when i see, for example, femboys """overdoing""" cute stuff cause i can understand that feeling of like "holy shit i can empathized with?? and i can just dive headfirst into expressing joy and stuff??? i dont have to be an unfeeling cold slab that only exists to be a tool??" so no surprise they may start somewhere that they dont quite stay at in terms of presentation

i think there's also connections to like, expressing joy in certain ways is considered unseemly if you're not "pretty" enough. like theres this idea that the exact same expressions of joy or vulnerability etc are disgusting or mockworthy or hilarious if the person is "ugly" or doesnt ~aesthetically fit that expression~. like ill see comments on little avatar(like vrchat) clips of femboys or other cutesy queers, where the comment's general idea is "their cute VR avatar may be expressing this happiness/excitement/whatever but haha guess what i bet they're real ugly in person!! oopsie!!" as if that somehow negates something.

so yeah, i feel like those things are all connected...