A sleeper knockout hit. The only knock I can give it is that it's not as broad in scope or replayable-feeling as some other GOTY contenders, but that tight scope is itself part of its immense appeal. Can't recommend highly enough.
Heresy: I honestly slightly prefer the Apollo trilogy - but only slightly. I like Trucy and Athena slightly better than Maya and while the script has fewer highs and more lows than the OG games, I feel like it's still ultimately more consistent.