thefifthnote

Trying out different platforms atm

  • They/them

21+ | PH
Weeb, book enthusiast, amateur artist. Dabbles in a lot of things.


rin-mari
@rin-mari

It is wild to me that there are people who think audiobooks is "cheating" literature.
Oh, so reading books is a competitive sport now?


NoelBWrites
@NoelBWrites

unironically, it makes me sad that so many people (even people who like books!) still treat reading as homework

"audiobooks don't count as reading" is a sentence that only makes sense if reading "counts" for something.

This is true for all the dumbass discourse around reading: Does fanfiction count as reading? Do graphic novels or comics count as reading? Do you have to read "the classics"? Is reading short/easy books "cheating"? Is it okay to not finish a book, should it "count" towards your total? The answer to all of these questions is: log off.

What standard are you holding yourself up to? Why does it matter at all? Who is "counting" and why? You're 37 you can't get a good grade in reading anymore, it's not real


Another way people treat reading as homework is when they treat reading books by marginalized authors as eating their fucking vegetables: "Oh this book taught me so much about the X experience or the Y struggle. This book is such great Z representation" And?? Is the book good? Did you enjoy it? Or was this just a title that checked off the requirements for your homework assignment and now you can go back to reading the books you actually wanted to read? Did you want to read at all or do you just think you should?

I say this as the snobbiest book person I know: read for enjoyment or don't read at all. Is reading good for you? Yeah, but so are a lot of things. Find the ones you like doing.


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @NoelBWrites's post:

I mean it may be true that if you used to read a lot and you can't right now, there may be something that's fucking with your attention span (yes, possibly phone or internet. But also stress, anxiety, depression, exhaustion, just more responsibilities in life, a million other things) and if reading is something you enjoyed and want to do again, it's worth trying to find ways to do it more often. It's always worth trying to find ways to do more of the things you enjoy and less of the things you don't

But it's not a moral failing to not enjoy reading. Or to want to read only certain books or at certain times of the year or whatever. If you're forcing yourself to read more... why? What is it that you want to get from reading and are there other ways to get that?

i'm very materialist when it comes to books, but i totally agree with this! some folks get so weird about e-books (and frankly most digital media) and it's very embarrassing to be around them. tablets are also part of the material world, i'm sure there are people that like the physicality of them in the same way i like the textures and sensations of books.

God I remember the "are ebooks real books" discourse from the early 2000s, how miserable

I love physical books! I always have at least one physical book that I'm reading at all times. I also love my kindle because of how many books I can get in it and I'm usually also reading something there. And I always have a book that I read on my phone because I like having that option when I'm out and about or tired of scrolling on social media. If the ADHD didn't make it so hard to follow audio narratives for me, I'd probably have a fourth book in audio format in the rotation as well lol