upthorn

I've been told I'm a person

Human life is more important
than property values.
All human beings deserve to be treated like human beings, not just straight white cisgendered males born in the US or its allies.


fedimast (barely)
brontosin.space/@upthorn
Discord
@upthorn

Around 18-20 years ago, as was common at the time, I got a lot of music files off of peer-to-peer filesharing services.

At that time, I was also heavily into anime, and did a lot of searching for anime soundtracks. I had recently watched an episode that had an insert song which particularly piqued my fancy, and went to try and find it.

I came across an entire soundtrack album for the series, labelled as being by Osamu Tezuka. Of course, it was well known that music file labelling on peer-to-peer services was untrustworthy. Everyone I knew had heard that one parody of "What if God Was One of Us", with female vocals, that was labelled as being by Weird Al. And, to the best of my knowledge, Osamu "The Godfather of Manga" Tezuka, had nothing to do with this anime, neither being the manga author, nor working for its studio. But I also had no good way of verifying the real composer at the time, so I left them as is, and let them worm their way into my playlists without any further thought.

Recently, I decided to get my music collection properly tagged and sorted, and got an automatic ID-and-tagger program. Basically shazam except you give it the file directly and it edits the tags.

Today, I got to my anime folder, and was surprised to learn that, actually, there's a second Osamu Tezuka, who had a career composing music for anime and tv soundtracks. And those MP3s were never mislabelled at all.

Imagine finding out that a mediocre comic book you read 20 years ago had its scripts, but not illustration, done by some guy named Walt Disney. But not that Walt Disney.

This is like that.


You must log in to comment.

in reply to @upthorn's post:

May I ask what your chosen ID-and-Tagger program ended up being? I've got several hundred gbs of music mostly hand-sorted, but the accuracy is terrible, and I've looked for automated solutions over the last decade, but nothing really did it well. Suggestions would be grand. :D

I was initially using lidarr for the purpose, but found its sorting model a little too rigid, as I have a fair number of music files that were never commercially released.

I wound up paying for Audio Ranger, which has tagging both by shazam-like audio fingerprint, and by manual lookup in album database. And, most importantly for me, will trust the existing tags when it can't find anything better.

I spent a couple days going through my library of ~9800 files in chunks of 50-300 that I felt comfortable verifying the results of. It wound up failing on 355 files, which mostly fell into the categoris of mashups, remixes of video game music, works in progress, or bootleg concert recordings.