This ain't much and it's taken me hours, but I decided to go back to my Belle model (ie, from the movie Belle) and this time build the eye and face loops from scratch and try to get that part of the face approximately correct for if I was modeling an actual person. I know from a "making of" article that they tried to keep their model fairly realistic with only concessions to make it sufficiently anime, so I figure that's a good approach here too.
It's definitely not there yet – looking at the left I can see I probably want to actually bring the brow ridge out more and the bottom corner of the mask out more to get more of a 90º v-shape pointing at the eyeball from this angle – but it's a damn sight better than my last attempt which just looked entirely wrong in this region and I couldn't work out why.
Faces are surprisingly difficult.